In a city like New York, where hot new restaurants pop up and disappear in a flash, Gramercy Tavern is a rock-solid classic that never disappoints. For over three decades, this iconic spot has been a favorite for locals, visitors, and loyal regulars who keep coming back for a reason.
Based on what recent diners are saying, it’s clear this NYC legend is still at the top of its game.
Service options: Reservations required · Outdoor seating · Private dining room
Address: 42 E 20th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
Menu: gramercytavern.com
Two Unique Experiences Under One Roof
One of the coolest things about Gramercy Tavern is that it’s like two restaurants in one. You can choose the experience that fits your mood:
- The Dining Room: This is the more formal, upscale area. It’s perfect for a special occasion, an anniversary, or any time you want a truly elegant meal. The atmosphere is cozy and sophisticated, making any dinner feel important.
- The Tavern: For a more relaxed, walk-in vibe, the Tavern is your spot. It’s lively, casual, and you can grab a seat at the bar or a table without a reservation. It’s perfect for a spontaneous lunch or a weeknight dinner.
No matter where you sit, the service is a huge part of the magic. Staff members are known for being incredibly warm and attentive—they remember faces, celebrate birthdays, and make you feel like a valued guest, not just another customer.
The Famous Tasting Menu: Is It Worth It?
In the Dining Room, the main event is the seasonal tasting menu. For a set price of around $175, you get a multi-course meal that showcases the best of what’s in season. Diners consistently rave about the seafood and lamb dishes, often calling the fish courses “flawless.” Even simple things, like the shrimp, are praised for being perfectly cooked.
The best part? Unlike many other high-end restaurants in NYC, Gramercy Tavern doesn’t hit you with annoying extra fees for certain dishes. The price is all-inclusive, which many feel is a great value. While a minor dish here or there might not be your absolute favorite, the standout courses and show-stopping desserts—like the famous ricotta fritters—make the entire meal unforgettable.
Don’t Underestimate the Simple Things
While the tasting menu gets a lot of attention, some of the most beloved items are the simplest. The complimentary bread is so fluffy and delicious that some people remember it more than their main course.
And then there’s the Tavern Burger. In a world full of trendy, thin smash burgers, this one is a thick, juicy, classic masterpiece that regulars swear by. Paired with a side of their must-order biscuits, it’s a perfect meal in itself.
Drinks, Decor, and More
The drink menu is just as thoughtfully crafted as the food. The sommeliers are great at recommending fantastic wines by the glass, and the cocktails, like the “Flatiron Friar,” are creative and delicious. The restaurant’s decor, with its rustic charm and beautiful seasonal flower arrangements, adds to the warm and inviting atmosphere. For warmer weather, the outdoor seating is a wonderful option.
The Final Word: A True NYC Icon
Gramercy Tavern isn’t just living off its famous name; it’s earning its reputation every single night. While it’s not a cheap night out, most guests agree that the price is justified by the complete package: incredible food, flawless service, and an atmosphere that feels both special and welcoming.
Whether you’re celebrating something big with their tasting menu or just craving one of the best burgers in the city, Gramercy Tavern delivers an experience that remains a benchmark for hospitality in New York City.
I’m a food enthusiast and reviewer with a passion for discovering and sharing exceptional dining experiences. Through honest and detailed restaurant reviews, I aim to help readers make informed choices and explore the best of the culinary scene.